The sports car segment is highly competitive, especially because most buyers believe higher prices equal better quality. As a result, they might not even give the 2022 Toyota Supra a second glance. Critics say the revived Supra is spacious and fun to drive — plus, it’s available for as low as $43,540. It’s even more difficult for a car to stand out in the luxury segment, where many cost upward of $90,000. The 2022 Porsche 718 Boxster bucks that trend, starting at just $62,600.

Despite these two sports cars’ below-average prices, Consumer Reports says they’re the best you can buy for over $40,000.